Team Draft Rankings by Total Points (2005-2009)

Team Draft Rankings by Total Points (2005-2009)

by -
123

After taking a look at the work of MLHS member “xxxnew” on ‘point production by round’ in the draft, a few of  you expressed an interest in seeing a chart on total points by drafted players for each team. FWIW, I put together the data in a couple of hours this afternoon.

Here’s how the teams stack up based on the five drafts between 2005-2009.

oie_31205357k09zQfWv
Recent Stanley Cup winners Chicago, Boston, Pittsburgh and Los Angeles are all right near the top. While Pittsburgh has a sizeable edge in points per pick (we all know why that is), Colorado leads the way in total points despite only three first round picks (Betwen Duchene, Statsny, Stewart, O’Rielly and Shattenkirk, drafting offence hasn’t been a problem).

A few quick caveats:

- This is obviously looking strictly at point production. A games played measure would yield some different results. If Detroit seems too low to you, for instance, consider that they drafted a goalie (McCollum) and two defencemen (Kindl, Smith) with their three first round picks and selected 19th, 29th and 30th in those three drafts.

- The asterisk next to the Habs’ top 5 pick is there because their fifth overall pick in 2005 was used on a goaltender, Carey Price.

 

The Leafs’ draft team comes off looking decent here for a few reasons:

– Points per pick puts the Leafs in 9th.

– The 2006 entry draft was big for the Leafs as far as these rankings go. This was the first year Director of Amateur Scouting Dave Morrison took over his current role. Their 7 draftees have generated 405 cumulative points so far, which is third most for that year. The Leafs trail only Boston and Washington in this draft,  who both had top 5 picks which were used to select Kessel and Backstrom respectively. All 7 Leaf picks except Tyler Ruegsegger have played NHL games (other picks were Tlusty, Kulemin, Stalberg, Holzer, Komarov). Oh, and let’s not forget the Leafs also got James Reimer out of this draft, a great pick that wouldn’t show in the points besides a few assists.

– The Leafs are one of only 6 teams over these 5 drafts to use a first round pick on a goaltender (Tuukka Rask), which wouldn’t play favourably into their points total but was a very good selection nonetheless (insert obligatory JFJ curse). The other 5 teams to draft goaltenders in the first round between 2005-2009 were Montreal (Carey Price), Calgary (Leland Irving), Detroit (Thomas McCollum), Los Angeles (Jonathan Bernier), and the Tampa Bay Lightning (Riku Helenius).

– Of the Leafs’ 4 first round picks, one was used on a goaltender and their fifth overall was used on defensive defenceman Luke Schenn, so their standing looks pretty good considering. Gotta love that Brian Burke managed to flip Schenn for van Riemsdyk.

– There was only 4 first round draft picks available to the Leafs’ draft team to begin with, which is bottom ten in the league. If you remove the goalies, only Detroit had fewer first round picks.

Alec Brownscombe is the founder of MapleLeafsHotStove.com, where he has written daily about the Leafs since September of 2008. He was also the editor of the 2009-12 Maple Leafs Annuals. You can contact him at [email protected]
87 comments
LeafsNut7
LeafsNut7

Oh dear, 34 combined picks only gave calgary 124 pts for a whopping 3.4 NHL produced pts per pick. They should just forfeit the draft each year cause it seems like a futile exercise. Ouch

Xxxxxnew
Xxxxxnew

Thought I'd try another way of looking at the draft. I added up the points in each each spot in the first round from 2006-2011 just to see what the differences are. I left out the last couple of years because most players haven't played yet.

There are some oddities because I didn't bother taking out goalies or defencemen, just looked at which rounds have produced the most points. For instance, Phil skews the meagre 5th pick spot where several defencemen were taken, accounting for 379 of the 558 points.

One real oddity is the 22nd pick which has 616 points which is way more than the 14 rounds above. Just happens Eberle, Pacioetti and Giroux got drafted at 22nd.

It does seem to show how important the first overall pick is for points production.

Total points over six seasons by draft pick position.

1. 1141

2. 873

3. 815

4. 756

5. 558

6. 556

7. 712

8. 395

9. 401

10. 317

11. 143

12. 496

13. 213

14. 340

15. 171

16. 211

17. 79

18. 224

19. 54

20. 146

21. 30

22. 616

23. 37

24. 186

25. 214

26. 284

27. 148

28. 212

29. 26

30. 26

Black_Hawk
Black_Hawk

man summer is so boring when it comes to hockey and then i feel bad i dont come on this site as much b/c theres not much to talk about. lol

Black_Hawk
Black_Hawk

man i hope we get kadri guys signed up soon 

Spayde_D
Spayde_D

MLHS - Every link posted is just looping back to this page. I'm not sure if everyone is experiencing it, but I know that several people are. It seems to be a problem with the Permalink settings behind the scenes. @Alec Brownscombe 

JWaterdrager
JWaterdrager

Anyone interested in the games played for the drafts from 2005-2009? 

Mind Bomb
Mind Bomb

Morning Folks, interesting article, thank you

 

Burtonboy
Burtonboy

What will our defense look like in 2 yrs time ? Here's my guess . Whats your's ?

Gardiner - Phaneuf

Rielly - Grandberg

Ranger - Franson 




B_Leaf
B_Leaf

I've noticed a lot of odds makers have the Bruins and Redwings on top of the Atlantic with the Leafs, Ottawa, and Montreal slotted just after. I still need to see how the changes made affect the Leafs...I really am not sure, although I like the fact we have Ranger on board and especially a healthy Gardiner. The addition of Clarkson gives our forwards some top line grit which should help.

But I also have to wonder if the Habs can repeat what they did last year...I think they have improved their team but they were terrible down the stretch and in the playoffs. That sends off warning bells about who they really are.

I think Ottawa will be right at the top with the Leafs and Bruins. They are a good team trending up. 

The Redwings ranking surprises me. They are getting old in some spots.

The Bruins should be fine but if Chara starts to decline they will feel it.

In summary I wouldn't be surprised to see the Leafs and Ottawa at the top. 

Just sayin...

Leafs rule
Leafs rule

@Xxxxxnew Interesting ,Thank you xxxxx ,that #22 draft position is like magically good

Xxxxxnew
Xxxxxnew

I don't know if I'd totally blame JVR, mainly because of the stat on MLHS earlier this year that showed Bozie didn't have even one primary assist on any of JVR's goals last year. Kind of odd, I thought.

Waiting4LSC
Waiting4LSC

Hey Alec: can you make it so that every link on PPP comes back to this page? :)

Waiting4LSC
Waiting4LSC

Wiski: what was Sparks about a little while ago where he was tweeting he was on his way back to Guelph?

Biltmore
Biltmore

@-Keon-

I remember reading a story years ago when Oates and Hull were playing together in St. Louis. A shift ended and the line was back on the bench. The other winger (can't remember who) didn't get a pass from Oates and said to Adam, "You know, I was open on that play..." 

Oates answered, "Yeah, I know."

Bring the Cup Home
Bring the Cup Home

@Burtonboy  

Rielly - Phaneuf

Gardiner - Franson

Grandberg - Fraser/Percy

That means we have traded Gunnar.  Wonder what we could get this trade deadline if we end up being able to bundle together Gunnar and Reimer due to Rielly's furthered development.  

 

theacs1966
theacs1966

@Burtonboy

                       Grandberg-Gardener

                         Reilly- Ranger/Franson

                         Percey- Gunner

                         Finn./Jonsson/or Blacker

Komas Taberle
Komas Taberle

@Burtonboy In 2 years I see the following

Gardiner Granberg

Rielly Franson

MacWilliam Finn

Percy

Phaneuf, Gunnerl traded for forwards and draft picks

VaiveOClockSomewhere
VaiveOClockSomewhere

@Burtonboy I'm not advocating it - but as a test, what if we take Phaneuf out of the picture. What potential lines do we have then.

Gardiner - Franson

Rielly - Granberg

Ranger - Blacker

I think we start looking a little soft without Dion.

VaiveOClockSomewhere
VaiveOClockSomewhere

@Burtonboy I can't see Gardiner and Phaneuf as a pairing. They both need a steady stay at home type.

Gunnar - Phaneuf

Gards - Franson

Rielly - Granberg

Possible Ranger takes Gunnars place beside Phaneuf if he's that good - and only wants to play in Toronto.

Leafs rule
Leafs rule

@B_LeafIn summary I wouldn't be surprised to see the Leafs and Ottawa at the top. " Great Fraser gets Neil to turtle and the T O fans go crazey,cant wait to c that lol

MaxwellHowe
MaxwellHowe

@B_Leaf Senators may be formidable.  And all with a self-imposed $55million cap.  Many on  this site underestimate that team.  Spezza, Michaelak, Ryan, Karlsson, Phillips, Turris, Zibenijad, Anderson stay healthy, look the F out.

Xxxxxnew
Xxxxxnew

Just shows how picks other than the top five or so in the first round can be like rolling the dice.

Burtonboy
Burtonboy

@VaiveOClockSomewhere @Burtonboy I would be surprised if Dion were moved but you just never know. We don't have anyone who does what he can do right now although some in Leafs management have been insinuating that Rielly will be a top all round D in the future. Can't remember which one of them said it but it came up in the interview series and he said Rielly was the best 2 way prospect we have at the moment . 

VaiveOClockSomewhere
VaiveOClockSomewhere

@dlb eh @Burtonboy So many potential D-lines going forward. There's still 3-4 players none of us have mentioned who could also steal a spot in 2 years (Fraser,Finn, Holzer, macwilliam)

Burtonboy
Burtonboy

@VaiveOClockSomewhere @Burtonboy I actually think Phaneuf would be better off if he had a more creative partner beside him. IMO Phaneuf is not a PMD , much more of a 2 way defenseman and as he gets older expect him to become even more defensively conscious. Also someone as effective as Gardiner at moving the puck out of his own end will take the pressure off in his own end. 

VaiveOClockSomewhere
VaiveOClockSomewhere

@dlb eh @VaiveOClockSomewhere @Xxxxxnew Good points. I guess I'm also thinking how good Lups and Kadri looked together. Whereas I can't recall seeing any chemistry between Kadri and JVR. I'm sure we'll see the line combo's change throughout the season. 

VaiveOClockSomewhere
VaiveOClockSomewhere

@dlb eh @Xxxxxnew I only remember seeing JVR dish off perfect saucer's to Kessel on 2-on-1's, multiple times. I think JVR and Kess should be a lock together when healthy. Just my opinion. Regardless, it looks like Carlyle has a few good problems to sort out this year.

Waiting4LSC
Waiting4LSC

BYU: thank you good sir. Ii remember reading the two tweets and feeling he was off of the Marlies (likely because of Gibson). I want Sparks to have Leaf success so was hoping there was nothing to the tweets.

theacs1966
theacs1966

@dlb eh @theacs1966 @Burtonboy Too many variables.  I want to see Gardener, Reilly, Percey,Grandberg, after that I don't know.  Will Finn Tear it up or regress, will Jonsson be ready in 2 yrs, will Blacker even be in the org, Phaneuf won't be, I don't think.  Plus I don't think Ranger plays anywhere else, so if there is a trade, Phaneuf/Gunnar/Blacker maybe even Reilly if its a big fish we go after, if say we lose Kessel.

Burtonboy
Burtonboy

@-Keon- Grandberg is a right d man so if he makes anyone expendable it would be on the right side where we really only have Franson and Phaneuf.

Burtonboy
Burtonboy

@-Keon- Would he even sign a contract without it I wonder?  He seems hell bent on staying in Toronto.

Burtonboy
Burtonboy

@VaiveOClockSomewhere @dlb eh @Burtonboy Absolutely. I just threw that line up out there to try and get a convo going . One has to think there are going to be quite a few changes on that d in the next few yrs. Gunnar ,Franson ,Fraser and the like are going to have to play well to keep a place I think

VaiveOClockSomewhere
VaiveOClockSomewhere

@dlb eh @VaiveOClockSomewhere @Burtonboy I agree Phaneuf is good on D. And Gards could be good on D with some seasoning. But they both like to skate the puck up the ice with frequency, and play their game better when they know their partner stays back - giving them more opportunity to wheel n' deal

GeorgeCastanza
GeorgeCastanza

@Dink @MaxwellHowe @B_Leaf They better look the fuck out for Toronto,because you know everybody thinks the leafs suck always, all the time. None of our players are elite, all one-dimensional, can't play a full season, none of our young players will ever mature , no one ever gets better, no one ever learns, etc etc etc etc