Game Review: Game #70, Red Wings 3 vs. Leafs 2

Game Review: Game #70, Red Wings 3 vs. Leafs 2

627

It’s amazing how quickly things can change at this time of the season. Combined with the loss in Washington, this four-point swing puts the Red Wings five back of the Leafs for a wildcard spot with two games in hand. That’s still a sizeable gap at this stage, but two consecutive losses by the Leafs combined with three straight wins each by Montreal and Tampa Bay suddenly has the Leafs in a wildcard spot and looking in the rear view mirror.

Conceding three goals in nine minutes and losing to the Capitals, and falling to the severely undermanned Red Wings — two non-playoff opponents — can pretty quickly erase all memories of two wins over Anaheim and Los Angeles. There’s a lesson to be gleaned here, though, and it’s not just that the Leafs are a frustrating team to cheer for (although that is also true); at this time of season, it’s not necessarily a good thing to be playing a team on the ropes versus one nestled comfortably in a playoff position.

That’s not to excuse the Leaf performance tonight. This time of season it’s about playing with urgency and desperation, and there wasn’t enough of it present on the Leaf bench in the first half of this game. The Leafs started to pick it up by the half way point, but unfortunately they were already down one and contending with Jimmy Howard’s A game.

The first period featured two good shifts from the third line of Peter Holland, David Clarkson and Mason Raymond, one or two good Kadri moments, and not much else. We were expecting more from the start after the loss to Washington.

Detroit’s 1-0 goal was the product of the Leafs getting caught with Franson and Gleason on the ice at the same time (along with Nyquist being fast). It started with a inattentive pass attempt by Kessel in the corner, before Gleason got caught in a tough situation with a 50/50 puck trickling between the blueline and top of the faceoff circle. Gleason was in between on trying to keep the puck in and backing off the line, while Franson maybe should’ve been quicker to recognize the danger and back off the point into a support position. Really, it was a demonstration of the obvious on why Franson and Gleason would never be a pairing as Nyquist burned through the middle and got a lucky bounce off of Reimer, who made the initial save but paddled it into his own net inadvertently afterward.

The second period went scoreless despite a slight Leaf edge (a second line of Clarkson, Lupul and Kadri made inroads) before the Leafs conceded a dagger-goal in the early 3rd. It was the product of a giveaway from Lupul high in the offensive zone that handcuffed Paul Ranger. A great shot by Nyquist, his second goal of the night, beat Reimer on the far side. Reimer had no chance on this one and it was a back breaker.

The Leafs’ powerplay had been stumbling all night long, with the first powerplay unit accomplishing next to nothing, before Rielly and Gardiner combined beautifully to get the Leafs back into this game eight minutes into the third. That was a play they talk about in their shared hotel room after lights out. Gardiner took off down the ice, Rielly instantly recognized it, and the hail mary play worked as well as it did for Phil Kessel against the Jets earlier in the season. The exuberant celebration between the roommates after combining for one of the Leafs’ prettiest goals of the season at a key time in the game was a special moment amid a frustrating night.

The ensuing full court press by the Leafs yielded some good chances, but it naturally came with the risk of conceding another. Sure enough, with Gardiner caught on a pinch, a 2 on 1 was finished off by Daniel Alfredsson to put this game out of reach. A JvR tip off a Phaneuf point shot made things interesting, but it was too little too late.

Notes

- In the final minute, the Leafs should’ve had a faceoff in the offensive zone with more time on the clock, but a missed call by the referees prevented that from happening. The puck clearly deflected off the Red Wing stick and into the crowd. The only reason the Leafs were in a position to take another offensive zone draw in the final 4 seconds was Bozak and JvR’s clever play off the faceoff in the neutral zone to give JvR a quick opening, where he got a shot off and an offensive zone draw followed.

- The set play at the end was designed to try to generate a shot from the Leafs’ best shooter, Kessel, with three bodies crashing the net. McClement had the worst faceoff percentage of the Leafs’ centers, making this a puzzling decision, but he did win the draw. It’s a split-second play where absolutely everything has to go right. Unfortunately, McClement won the draw so cleanly that Kessel was forced to scramble.

Fail horn

Were the Leafs better off going with a right handed faceoff taker (Bozak) and trying to win this to Phaneuf on the right? It’s all academic.

- Something has to change on the first powerplay unit. Franson and Phaneuf cannot gain a clean zone entry without dumping it in and asking for a low-probability puck retrieval from that forward group. The Leafs scored their late goal with Phaneuf on the right; there’s no reason he can’t shift over and play with Gardiner or Rielly. The performance of powerplay unit #1 was atrocious tonight.

- Morgan Rielly put on a show leading rushes late in this game. There were a number of times he prevented a break the other way, as well, with a hard 4 or 5 strides to make up the ground. He’s already an amazing option to have late in games with his ability to join the attack and still be the first man back. Amid the frustration of this loss, that’s something special to hang your hat on.

- Peter Holland played just 7 minutes in this game, with his minutes slashed once the Leafs fell behind. He played the least among Leaf forwards. This didn’t make much sense. He was a part of two of the Leafs’ better shifts in the first period. It wasn’t like the Leafs’ top line was on their game tonight, either.

- Time to abandon 7 defencemen for tomorrow’s game and go with four forward lines in a back to back situation? I’d say so.

- 4 goals in his last 6 for Jake Gardiner. 8 points in his last 10 for Dion Phaneuf. 4 points for Rielly in his last 7. The D continues to do its part offensively down the stretch.

#ReimerGate

Carlyle assessed Reimer’s game as “OK, just OK” tonight, while Reimer thought he was “good but not great” when told of Carlyle’s remarks. Twitter was then quick to connect the dots between the following two tweets, one from Reimer’s agent (I can’t say whether Reimer’s agent was responding to Carlyle’s comments or general Reimer criticism):

First off, Bernier’s ability to make multiple big saves in a game and steal a victory at various points this season has set the bar high, but it doesn’t mean Reimer should be expected to steal games or else he sucks. And it wasn’t a case of Reimer playing poorly or making no good saves tonight. (Reimer had a particularly nice save with his toe on the doorstep one minute into the 2nd period).

However, the chances were pretty even in this game and Leafs needed a save on one of those three odd man chances or breakaways. Should the Leafs be giving up those chances? In a perfect world, no. But Detroit got a save (Kessel breakaway) the Leafs didn’t. That makes the difference in a single game of hockey.

There are lots of questions for Carlyle this season and this game was no exception, but I can’t honestly criticize his description of Reimer as “okay” when my assessment after the game was no different. It wasn’t Reimer’s fault, as in there weren’t any decisively bad goals that caused the team to lose, but I thought Jimmy Howard was better.

The way a quote sounds when it’s isolated and disseminated on Twitter can also come off much differently than how it sounds in real time. Listening back to the post game videos, neither comment was all that inflammatory.

Highlights

-

It is going to be a brutally tough turnaround leg against Tampa Bay back at the ACC tomorrow night, and now it’s one where the Leafs badly need some points.

Fenwick chart for 2014-03-18 Maple Leafs 2 at Red Wings 3

EV fenwick chart for 2014-03-18 Maple Leafs 2 at Red Wings 3

Leafs vs Red Wings

Toronto Maple Leafs vs Detroit Red Wings

DETROIT STATISTICS

GOALIEDEC.SHOTSSAVESSAVE %MIN.
Jimmy Howard (15-16-10)W33310.93960:00:00
PLAYERGATOI+/-SOGPIMFWFLHITSBSTAKEGIVE
Daniel Alfredsson1017:22120013000
Todd Bertuzzi0015:12030201000
Danny DeKeyser0025:09:00110000200
Cory Emmerton009:21010420010
Jonathan Ericsson0013:09000001201
Landon Ferraro009:45010002100
Johan Franzen0018:16142510000
Luke Glendening0018:140128111100
Jakub Kindl0015:39-130004101
Niklas Kronwall0123:35200000201
Brian Lashoff0013:28-100001200
David Legwand0117:301301171021
Drew Miller0020:47020001000
Gustav Nyquist2016:03160000011
Kyle Quincey0119:44222000210
Riley Sheahan0014:16100560000
Brendan Smith009:43120000100
Tomas Tatar0015:21102102010

TORONTO STATISTICS

GOALIEDEC.SHOTSSAVESSAVE %MIN.
James Reimer (11-10-1)L31280.90357:45:00
PLAYERGATOI+/-SOGPIMFWFLHITSBSTAKEGIVE
Troy Bodie008:06010000000
Tyler Bozak0019:55-1008102010
David Clarkson0013:41-120000020
Cody Franson0020:25-110001100
Jake Gardiner1021:15-130001011
Tim Gleason0011:39-102002100
Carl Gunnarsson0016:15000001200
Peter Holland007:17000211010
Nazem Kadri0018:48-1201090010
Phil Kessel0020:54-170000000
Nikolai Kulemin0016:51030131120
Joffrey Lupul0119:45052001010
Jay McClement009:330007121010
Dion Phaneuf0123:07110001100
Paul Ranger0012:47-100002400
Mason Raymond0016:46022000100
Morgan Rielly0114:50-120001113
James van Riemsdyk1022:21-142012100
Alec Brownscombe is the founder of MapleLeafsHotStove.com, where he has written daily about the Leafs since September of 2008. He was also the editor of the 2009-12 Maple Leafs Annuals. You can contact him at [email protected]

SIMILAR ARTICLES

572 comments
Chris Jay
Chris Jay

Where the eff is Bolland? I thought he was gonna be back right after the Olympic break!

CanuckUKinToronto
CanuckUKinToronto

All the comments today are associated with Reimer/Carlyle's comments.. which really was not critical....


Top 6 not producing.. people keep saying top line.. but neither Kadri or Lupul have scored since Flyers 5 games ago and we already do not expect a goal from the other winger (Clarkson- 4 goals all year and Kule no goal in 15 games).  That is a statement right there.


Then defensive gaffs of Franson, Gleason and Ranger


We should be talking how GOOD Gardiner and Rielly have looked (Gardiner all round game- Rielly a lot of giveaways in his own zone last night but offensively)

Yan28
Yan28

Marlies playing their last game with the Lake Erie Monsters today. 3+ fights guaranteed.

Bruffins
Bruffins

Hypothetical question, if the Leafs put Clarkson on waivers would Edmonton pick him up?

Yan28
Yan28

@Chris Jay He's been cleared to play for a while. Time to forget about him.

peterbleafs
peterbleafs

@wiski The power of dreams and the purity of sports heroes.  Awesome.

loomx
loomx

@Belfour20  Fun fact: Morgan Reilly has 11 PP points with 114 minutes of PP time. That's a better PPP/PPTOI than Franson.

peterbleafs
peterbleafs

@Belfour20 We need a new lineup.  Gleason plays wing when Gardiner and Rielly are on the ice.  They rush up supported by center and winger and Gleason swings back to defensive side of the play.

peterbleafs
peterbleafs

@Belfour20 That was truly an amazing goal showing the creativity potential of those two.

Bruffins
Bruffins

@Belfour20  

they were amazing, great to see "their play" work so well. I was also legitimately mad watching how much better they were than Franson and seeing us score when Dion was on the right side again (i swear it's every time)

Yan28
Yan28

@Jmessih they win today and on Saturday and things will be looking good again.

Jon5200
Jon5200

@Jmessih I wouldnt say so......Leaf Nation is strong enough to have disagreements!!!

loomx
loomx

@Bruffins  Nope. Only a moron would take on that contract...

wendelsway1
wendelsway1

@Belfour20 @Chris Jay  Not likely, IMO......he is recovering from a severe injury....takes time to heal properly, rehab and strengthen....he's just not game ready....yet.  Really don't like to assume that it is somehow contract related.....doesn't say much about his character....and his character has never been questioned....heart and soul, team player  :)

Leafs rule
Leafs rule

@wendelsway1 @Belfour20@Chris Jay And The leafs are still in 5th place in the division, Yeaa leafs ,Next game they will be better with or without Bolland ,just wait and see ,assuming what is this assuming you speak of lol Go Leafs go  ,knows ww1 knows but others here ?

peterbleafs
peterbleafs

@KulieFTW @peterbleafs@Belfour20@Bruffins@loomxIt needs to come out if he is playing with an injury that affected him all year, because he is approaching bum status.  Even so I do not want him back on the team.  Now if an injury turns out to be a problem then Nonis/Carlyle have to be held accountable putting a bum on PP1 and wathcing him flail around all year like a turtle.

peterbleafs
peterbleafs

@Belfour20 @Bruffins@loomxNo way Franson is back next year.  Too bad for him, but this year he has shown us all what we would have paid $4million a year for.  Good move by Nonis to not give him a deal.  

wendelsway1
wendelsway1

@Bruffins @wendelsway1 @Belfour20  I know, eh......glad some have realized it's just a part of development......he's gonna be a beauty for us...just needs more time to hone his skills.  :)

peterbleafs
peterbleafs

@Bruffins @wendelsway1@Belfour20I think Nonis in a way must be shielding Gardiner and Reilly from having to much responsibility, ie PP1 responsibility.  Next year I see them as being minute leaders in several areas and as a result, points leaders as well.

Greg Fenton
Greg Fenton

@FrankFerrant @Greg Fenton  I would agree there was probably a bit of "wanting to make a splash" in there. But I certainly wouldn't agree that it was just Clarkson being from Toronto and nothing else. ANd there certainly was reason to expect good offensive output from him. 

FrankFerrant
FrankFerrant

@Greg Fenton He was still overrated by management. It seemed to me that they just wanted to sign him because he was the biggest name out there and it would look like a victory for them, well hindsight is 20/20. He's somewhere in between Lucic and Kulemin.... just more expensive and physically smaller. I'd give him one more season at the most, than trade him for anything at all. 

Greg Fenton
Greg Fenton

@FrankFerrant @BBirde @loomx @Bruffins  Thats not fair. 


Clarkson pretty much had back to back 30 goal seasons, which had a lot to do with people really liking the idea of him coming here. It wasn't only because he is from Toronto. 

FrankFerrant
FrankFerrant

@BBirde @loomx @Bruffins  Ya but that just means you gotta pick your spots a little more carefully, Clarkson is just a smaller version of Kulemin but he's from Toronto so everyone fell in love with the idea of signing him. I hope he does good and makes me shutup like Bozak did this year.... but watching the guy is fucking painful. Maybe he will be better once Bolland is back, whenever that happens. I guess they were supposed to be paired up. 


I'd rather have re-signed MacArthur to 5 years 3M than fucking Clarkson. Oh wait sorry Randy rode him out of town... 

RandomScrub
RandomScrub

@loomx @Bruffins @BBirde  Do you guys just not realize that the price of players is going up? The days of Sundin and the boys getting paid for 4m as a high end contract are over. 

loomx
loomx

@Bruffins @BBirde @loomx  Exactly. I like what Clarkson could bring. But even if he plays like he did in New Jersey(don't say 30 goals, that's not him) He STILL won't be worth the contract.

Bruffins
Bruffins

@BBirde @loomx @Bruffins  

he will never be fine with that contract, best case scenario is that he minimizes the damages and scores like 20 goals