Weekend Mashup: $2.2 million apart


Updating on Elliot’s excellent piece about Monday’s arbitration case, word is the Maple Leafs and Cody Franson have submitted their initial proposals and are more than $2 million apart on salary.

Being $2.2 million apart probably isn’t outrageous as far as this nasty process goes, but it certainly sounds like a huge divide when the player’s desired contract figure is more than double that of the club.

Always a demeaning process, the Maple Leafs have anchored their offer as if Franson is worth the same as he was paid on his previous one-year deal, which Franson felt was a pittance last summer and set out to prove he could do what he did in the half-season over the full slog in 2013-14; he posted only 4 more points in 34 fewer games despite two more minutes of time on ice per game at even strength (along with very similar PP time). Franson has asked for Slava Voynov money; that obviously doesn’t jive in terms of age/potential and even strength production, which actually decreased from the shortened season to the full one for Franson (16 EVPts in 2012-13, 15 EVPts in 2013-14). A big part of that dip in 5v5 production is attributable to his 41.1% zone starts (versus 45.5% in 2012-13) against better competition as the Leafs looked to him as a second-pair guy at even strength, although these type of numbers aren’t used in arbitration hearings.

A half-way split would make it a reasonably attractive contract at $3.1 million per season, able to be moved for value if the Leafs go that route. The walkaway point is $3.5 million, but a figure south of $4 million seems unlikely to be walked away from.

It becomes a question of whether or not the Leafs think last season indicated he’s capable of handling top 4 minutes well or not, and if he’s a fit on the rejigged blueline. If they think he’s worth it and can play those minutes on a good team, pushing Phaneuf to the left side and lining up Robidas, Franson and Polak down the right is a distinct possibility. If not, the Leafs will be hoping this contract settlement comes in at a nice marketable price and will proceed to try to move him.

The Leafs have $11 million in cap space remaining with Franson, Jake Gardiner and James Reimer left to sign, but there’s probably a little more room than that given there’s 15 forwards currently on the cap chart.

This will be an interesting situation to follow early this week.


Weekend Links:

Previous articleThe Cody Franson Arbitration: What is he Worth?
Next articleCody Franson Signs with Toronto Maple Leafs for 1 year, $3.3m
Founded in 2008, Maple Leafs Hotstove (MLHS) has grown to be the most visited unofficial team-focused hockey website online (Quantcast).Independently owned and operated, MLHS provides thorough and wide ranging content, varying from news, opinion and analysis, to pre-game and long-form game reviews, a weekly feature piece, the "Leafs Notebook", along with a Web TV show the "Maple Leaf Hangout".
  • Bon Scott was a Leaf fan

    Was reading the link Declan posted in the previous Mashup about the prospects who stood out at the recent camp….very curious to see how Connor Brown progresses.

  • BigTO

    I’d consider walking away from anything over $3.5 million myself. I’m worried he becomes an odd man out if his PP bubble bursts and starts looking at a burden at a larger figure than that.  Not seeing enough value at 5v5 personally.

  • djamon

    @BigTO You can’t walk away from an asset who can easily be traded. Not over a few hundred thousand.

  • Cloud09

    Just a FYI, the link to Elliot’s article takes you to the Leafs Capgeek page, not MLHS.

  • Alec Brownscombe

    Cloud09 He wrote that page.
    Jks, thanks.

  • hometeem

    djamon wonderin if a deep team would pay a premium if franny was on a one year deal and we ate most of his salary.  is their a limit on how much of a guys contract u can eat?

  • djamon

    hometeem 50%. But it wouldn’t require that much.

  • rustynail

    https://twitter.com/adater https://twitter.com/adater/status/490695087760744451
    Canada upsets USA 8-5 in world lacrosse championship https://twitter.com/hashtag/worldlax?src=hash  UPSETS? WTF we own lacrosse

  • Xxxxxnew

    Field lacrosse.

  • Alec Brownscombe

    Do we peddle Franson and give Del Zotto that chance to “prove doubters wrong” close to home?
    Only 24, young for a D.
    2 40 pt seasons to his name already. He’ll put it together again in the right circumstances.
    Sheltered minutes in T.O. those circumstances?